WE PUT EVERYTHING YOU LOVE ABOUT COOKIES IN EVERY BOX WE MAKE.

Apple Cider Molasses

You can’t get any more autumnal that this.

Except the magical smell when they’re about to come out of the oven. That we just can’t ship.

Mothers have been stirring butter, sugar and flour together for years, pulling fresh cookies out of the oven in kitchens large and small. Why? Because cookies are the best way we know to say, “I love you.” When I started Mom in the Mail, I was inspired by my own amazing mother and by a drive to perfect recipes for the classic treats that meant so much to me growing up.

We bake cookies that make you happy the minute you take a bite, like Chocolate Chip Cookies, Double Fudge Brownies, Snickerdoodles, Oatmeal Raisin Cookies, and Peanut Butter Cookies. Our recipes are tried and true, loaded with good old-fashioned ingredients, and each one is scooped and baked by hand, made to order just for you.

Cookies are available by the dozen (or more!) in our festive gift boxes and care packages, and a la carte in individual four packs.

Our curated cookie collections include sure-to-please fan favorites, classic and new, but feel free to scroll down, find the cookies that speak to you, and create the cookie mix of your dreams.

We’re very, very proud of all of our cookies, and get a huge thrill every time we hear you love them too.

“I received the box of cookies and treats today. Wow. So good.””

SHOP COOKIES

Ingredient Lists

NOW BAKING: CLASSIC COOKIES AND TREATS

Featured

Classic Chocolate Chip

The chocolate chip cookie, perfected. Three types of semi-sweet chocolate folded in, with a generous sprinkle of Maldon salt on top.

Black Bottom White Russian Blondies

Our fabulous blondie, enhanced with a big glug of Kahlua, espresso and white chocolate chips, smoothed on top of a layer of rich fudge brownies. You should probably order a double.

Cookies 'N Cream

Crunchy Oreo(R) bits crushed into a buttery cookie base, along with plenty of creamy white chocolate chips.

Double Fudge Pretzel Brownie

The ultimate brownie (in our opinion!) - intensely dark and fudge-y, topped with crunchy chocolate pretzels!

Funfetti Snickerdoodles

These have a cult following of their very own, for good reason! Sparkling cinnamon sugar on the outside, decadently delicious on the inside. NEW - Cinnamon Roll version - just for the holidays!

Kitchen Sink Cookies

We raid the snack jars for these! Hershey(R) bars, M&Ms(R), crispy potato chips, and those sprinkle-covered circus animal cookies, too!

Maple Pecan Pie Bars

Like eating a great pecan pie, but in a bar form!

Peanut Butterpalooza

Peanut Butter Everything! Peanut Butter cookie dough with chocolate peanut butter pretzels, peanut butter chips, peanut butter sandwich cookies and peanut butter rice crispy treats, too. It sounds like too much, but they’re honestly Ah-Mazing!

S'Mores Blondies

Like being around the campfire, without having to sleep in the forest! Toasted marshmallows, Golden Grahams, Hershey(R) Bars, and a hit of smoked salt top our buttery Blondie bars.

Order a Curated Cookie Box

Create your own Dozen

Order COOKIES A la Carte

NOW BAKING: DAIRY-FREE, EGG-FREE AND GLUTEN-FREE COOKIES

Since care packages for college kids are a huge part of our company DNA, we expanded our menu to include cookie gifts for parents with gluten-free, dairy-free or egg-free diets to consider. It turns out that grown-ups with these dietary situations also love these special varieties. NOTE for vegan clients: we do use traditional refined sugar in all of our baked goods, which is not strictly vegan.

Featured

Triple Almond Milk Chocolate (GF)

Almond butter, almond flour, almond extract, lots of milk chocolate chips and zero gluten!

Apple Cider Granola (DF, EF)

Everything you love about Fall in one amazing bite - crunchy granola, dried Honeycrisp apples, and a big glug of our homemade Apple Cider Molasses. Crispy on the edge, a tiny bit tangy, and, oh, by the way? No dairy, no eggs!

Apple Cider Molasses (DF)

We make our own molasses with crisp apple cider, add all the Autumn spices, and throw in some caramelized sugar bits. So so good!

Dark Chocolate Crinkles with Walnuts (DF, GF)

Two kinds of dark chocolate, a hint of espresso, crunchy toasted walnuts and zero dairy or gluten. Rolled in a snowy coating of powdered sugar and baked until they crack. Melt-in-your mouth amazing!

Hot Cocoa Brownies (DF, EF)

Our Double Fudge Brownies set a high bar, so it took a while for us to develop a dairy- and egg-free version to join the family. Topped with mini marshmallows and chunks of dark chocolate, these truly deserve their place!

Oatmeal Coconut Raisin Walnut (GF)

Don’t tell the other cookies, but these just might be Mom’s favorites. Rolled oats, plump raisins, chewy coconut, and toasty walnuts, with a hint of cinnamon and nutmeg, and zero gluten! We roll ‘em in crunchy sugar just before baking for a little extra magic!

Crispy Oatmeal Shortbread (EF, GF & VE available)

Crispy, rich shortbread, with nutty rolled oats. Egg free and addictive - and, no tricks - there are GF and Vegan variations available!

Peanut Butter Oatmeal Toasted Pecan (DF, EF, GF)

Chock full Crispy Oats, Peanut Butter, and Toasted Pecans, plus a ripe banana as the secret agent. 100% gluten, dairy, and egg free.

Toasted Marshmallow Brownies (GF)

Decadent with a double dose of chocolate and made with almond flour, golden toasted marshmallows take these gluten-free brownies over the top.

Vegan-ish Chocolate Chip (DF, EF)

An awesome Chocolate Chip Cookie that just happens to be free of dairy and eggs. Oh yeah!

Vegan-ish Chocolate Chip Shortbread (DF, EF)

Dare we use the word “buttery” for these dairy-free wonders? Yes, yes, we do. Crisp yet tender, with chunks of dark chocolate and crunchy raw sugar edges.

Order A Gluten-Free Cookie Box

Order a Vegan-ish Cookie Box

Order Cookies A la Carte

Please note that although selected varieties of our treats exclude certain allergens, all cookies are prepared in a kitchen where flour, nuts, and dairy products, like butter and milk, are present.

SEASONAL COOKIES - YOU’ll HAVE TO WAIT (or ask nicely!)

These treats rotate in with the seasons, or as we get inspired in the kitchen. That being said, we get that you may fall in love, and we are happy to do special orders by request. 3 dozen minimum/variety required.

Featured

Almond Jam Thumbprints

Buttery rich cookies with fresh fruit jammy middles. Like Grandma makes, but way better. In the Summer box, these feature our house-made strawberry jam!

Apple Cinnamon Snickerdoodle (DF, EF)

Imagine a crisp-edged, tender-middled Snickerdoodle with a little tang from our Apple Cider Molasses and apple chip dust, rolled in crunchy cinnamon sugar. Then imagine it’s actually free of dairy and eggs. Wow!

Banana Walnut Chip (DF, EF)

Crispy caramelized edges, sweet-salty chewy inside, made with potato chips, plantain chips, and big chunks of walnuts. And ZERO dairy or eggs!

Black Bottom Cadbury Blondies

A thin layer of our rich fudge brownies, with chewy/buttery blondie batter and decadent Cadbury(R) chocolate eggs baked on top. A seasonal special!

Black Bottom Peanut Butter Blondies

Two great tastes that taste great together! We lay our rich fudge brownies on the bottom, then cover with our brown butter blondie batter, amped up with peanut butter and chopped peanut butter cups. Truly magical.

Cadbury Chocolate Chip

The chocolate chip cookie, amped up for Spring, with Cadbury(R) eggs folded right in. As always, we add a generous sprinkle of Maldon salt on top.

Campfire Cookies!

Our signature brown butter cookie dough, with baby marshmallows, graham cereal, Hershey Bars(R) and toasty oatmeal folded in, and baked with a light sprinkle of hickory smoked salt. As the kids say, these are FIRE!

Caramel Apple Blondies - NEW!

We infuse our buttery blondie batter with three different forms of tart fall apples, swirl melted salted caramel chips on top, and cover the entire batch with an apple cider glaze. If you love fall apple season, this is the cookie for you!

Chocolate Cherry Toffee

Our Chocolate Chip Cookie base, with a splash of almond extract, Heath(R) toffee bits, and tangy dried cherries. A beautiful balanced treat!

Chocolate Sandwich Cookies

We’re not allowed to say these are just like OREOS(R), so we’ll say they’re BETTER than OREOS(R) instead. Dark chocolate-y outsides, creamy middles, the works!

Cookie Butter & Jelly

A brown butter Blondie with cinnamon cookie butter folded in, topped with bright raspberry preserves and a dusting of powdered sugar.

Cinnamon Roll Blondies

Everything you love about a great cinnamon roll, all wrapped up in our buttery blondie batter with a cream cheese swirl baked right in! And in the Fall, we amp them up even more with the full Pumpkin Spice treatment. You're welcome!

Cranberry Coconut Chew

One of Sharon’s very favorite holiday cookies - crispy-chewy-melt-in-your mouth buttery with orange zest, tart cranberries, and the unexpected touch of sweet coconut.

Double Chocolate Mocha Drop

Chocolate-Chocolate Chip Cookie, with a generous dollop of Maya’s incredible Coffee Brigadeiro right in the middle.

Double Fudge Brownie Hearts

Our fabulous fudge brownies, with a healthy sprinkle of festive M&Ms(R) baked in, cut into hearts for the holiday.

Easter Bunny Brownies

Our Double-Fudge Brownies, with a bountiful amount of Cadbury(R) eggs/Marshmallow Peeps (R) (or both!) added in. Easter Bunny approved!

Fruitcake Sables

All the good parts of the fruitcake (spices, booze, fruit, nuts!) with none of the bad stuff (the actual fruitcake!). One of Mom’s personal favorites.

Hamantaschen

Buttery shortbread surrounds our house-made fillings, in our version of these classic shaped Purim treats.

Lemon Snickerdoodles

Our snickerdoodle recipe - but sunnier! Lemon zest and juice for zing, plus crushed Lemon Head(R) candies added to the sugar coating.

Lemon Raspberry Shortbread Bars (EF, VE available)

Crisp, ultra buttery crust and topping, a touch of lemon zest, with a layer of tart organic raspberry preserves. A completely dairy-free version is available, too!

Matzo 'Crack' (EF)

Crisp matzo crackers and buttery toffee, slathered in chocolate and topped with almonds, dried fruit, peppermint bits, or a simple sprinkle of sea salt. GF versions available!

Mixed Berry Snickerdoodles

Our snickerdoodle recipe - Summertime version! Bursts of dried blueberries, raspberries, and strawberries, a hint of lemon in the batter, and tart berry sugar coating. Fabulous!

Oatmeal Pecan Scotchie

Everyone’s childhood favorite, updated with chopped toasted pecans and a sprinkle of toffee bits on top.

Orange Sugar Sables

A brand new cookie - and so worth the wait! Savor the bright citrus flavor of orange infused into every bite of these melt-in-your mouth sugar sables. Perfect on their own, even better with a cup of tea and a book. - Egg/Dairy-Free version available!

Peanut Butter Cookies

Crispy sugar-coated edges, tender middles, and chock full of peanut butter flavor. If you like Peanut Butter Cookies, you’re gonna LOVE these.

Peanut Butter Cup Brownies

Two great tastes that go together even better when they’re baked into a decadent fudge brownie. A seasonal special!

Peanut Butter Peanut Butter Cup

Our fantastic Peanut Butter Cookies go to 11, with the addition of mini Peanut Butter Cups to the batter. You’ll definitely go nuts for these!

Peppermint Bark Brownies

The jolliest brownie you’ll ever eat - our famous Double Fudge recipe, with chopped up Peppermint Bark folded into every bite!

Red, White & Blue-kies 'N Cream

A patriotic (and delicious) variation - adds tangy dried cherries and sweet dried blueberries to our beloved Cookies ‘N Cream recipe.

Snickerdoodles (GF, VE)

A by-request recipe we wish we’d invented years ago - a dairy, egg, and wheat-free version of the childhood classic, with all the cinnamon yumminess of the original.